Since Enterprise, Alamo, and National all operate from the same facility at Cyril E. King Airport (STT) on St. Thomas, comparing their prices can help you get the best deal. Here is what to know about rental brand pricing at STT.
Same Brands, Different Prices
Although all three brands are part of Enterprise Holdings, they set their prices independently based on their target markets. Alamo is typically the most affordable for leisure travelers, while National tends to have higher base rates reflecting its premium positioning.
Factors That Affect Pricing
- Season: Peak season (December–April) commands the highest rates
- Vehicle type: SUVs and Jeep Wranglers cost more than economy cars
- Duration: Weekly and monthly rentals often have lower daily rates
- Loyalty program: Member rates can be significantly lower
- Booking time: Booking in advance is almost always cheaper
Alamo Pricing
Alamo generally offers the lowest base rates for leisure travelers. Their Alamo Insiders program provides additional discounts. For a standard family vacation to St. Thomas, Alamo is often the most budget-friendly option.
Enterprise Pricing
Enterprise's pricing sits in the middle. While not always the cheapest, Enterprise offers a strong balance of price, service, and vehicle quality. Enterprise Plus members may access member-only deals.
National Pricing
National typically has the highest base rates, reflecting its premium positioning. However, Emerald Club members can get excellent value through the Emerald Aisle, where you might drive away in an SUV for the price of a midsize car.
Tips for the Best Rate
- Compare all three brands for your specific dates
- Join all three free loyalty programs before booking
- Book as early as possible, especially for peak season
- Consider whether the Emerald Aisle upgrade potential offsets a higher base rate
- Check for weekly or monthly rates if staying more than 5 days
